Urban Legends II

Urban Legends II is a sequel to the horror anthology film Urban Legends, released in 1998. Unlike the first film which was released straight-to-video, this movie received a somewhat wider release. The film was first released on HBO, but had never received a home media release due to threats of legal action by the producer of the first film as it was made without his authorization.

Keeping with the principal of the previous installment, this film features three tales, modeled after myths surrounding goings on in a neighborhood, including a spiteful girl who succumbs to a supposedly debunked illness that turns her into a monkey, a statue passing on a werewolf-like curse to a girl who stares right into its eyes and a boy who suspects a classmate is a vampire, unaware that one is actually among them.

Plot
The film is divided into three segments, each bookended by a librarian who goes over items relating to the stories.

Take a Look in the Mirror
Edgar watches a vampire movie with his friends Jake and Toby. Afterwards, due to a number of coincidences, Edgar is convinced that Toby might be a vampire. More oddities surrounding him come up and it only furthers Edgar's suspicions. Jake attempts to convince Edgar otherwise, but following a gruesome murder at the park, Edgar takes matters into his own hands, intending to drive a stake through Toby's heart.

He breaks into Toby's house, while Jake goes in through the front door and confronts both, but when Jake tells him to look in the mirror to put his suspicions to rest, he sees Toby's reflection, but not Jake's, revealing that he was a vampire all along. Before Jake could kill him, Toby does so and the unveiling of a full moon reveals him to be a werewolf (this was hinted at when Toby burned himself on a silver frame.), but in his attempt to kill Edgar, he winds up biting into a Wolfsbane charm Edgar has, which kills him.